Whyscope Question 85 Chapter 8 · Food & Kitchen

Where does chocolate come from?

Chocolate starts on the cacao tree. Its flowers grow on the trunk and are pollinated by tiny flies called midges, and a flower can become a pod of seeds in pulp. Fresh seeds are bitter, nothing like chocolate! The seeds ferment for 3–8 days, often under banana leaves, then dry in the sun. The beans are roasted, cracked into nibs and ground into a thick paste for chocolate.

whyscope.org/q/85

How do we know?

↻ One of the pages with a moving picture

Old pots held cacao clues that were 5,300 years old.

Flowers on thecacao trunk1 A flower becomes apod of seeds2 The seeds ferment,then dry in thesun3 Roasted, crackedand ground intochocolate4
Simplified and not to scale. The numbers match the steps below.
  1. Chocolate starts on the cacao tree. Its flowers grow on the trunk and are pollinated by tiny flies called midges.
  2. A flower can become a pod of seeds in pulp. Fresh seeds are bitter, nothing like chocolate!
  3. The seeds ferment for 3–8 days, often under banana leaves, then dry in the sun.
  4. The beans are roasted, cracked into nibs and ground into a thick paste for chocolate.

Old pots from a site in Ecuador held cacao starch grains, a cacao chemical and cacao DNA. Cacao was grown there 1,500 years earlier than people thought.

The Mayo-Chinchipe people used cacao in the foothills of the Andes. People in South America were using cacao about 5,300 years ago.

Today the beans are fermented, dried and roasted before they become chocolate.

Wow number

5,300 People in South America were using cacao about 5,300 years ago!

Myth or fact?

Chocolate was first grown in Central America. Myth. The oldest signs so far are in South America, in Ecuador.

Raw cacao seeds taste like chocolate. Myth. They are bitter until they are fermented and roasted.

Think about it

Why do you think chocolate from different farms can taste different?

Where in the world?

Santa Ana-La Florida, Ecuador where the Mayo-Chinchipe people used cacao in the foothills of the Andes — 4.6° S, 79.0° W.

Where these facts come from

Every number on page 85, and who measured it

This page tells us how scientists found 5,300-year-old cacao clues in Ecuador.

Sweet discovery: New UBC study pushes back the origins of chocolate — The University of British Columbia in Canada
news.ubc.ca/2018/10/sweet-discovery-new-ubc-study-pushes-back-the-origins-of-chocolate

We checked it on 31 October 2026

This page is the science paper about the oldest known use of cacao.

The use and domestication of Theobroma cacao during the mid-Holocene in the upper Amazon — Nature, a famous science journal
nature.com/articles/s41559-018-0697-x

We checked it on 31 October 2026

This page tells us how cacao seeds are fermented, dried and roasted.

The Science of Good Chocolate — Smithsonian magazine, from the Smithsonian museums
smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/science-good-chocolate-180970658

We checked it on 31 October 2026

This page tells us about the tiny flies that pollinate cacao flowers.

You Wouldn't Have Chocolate Without Invisible Flies and Extreme Yeast — Smithsonian magazine, from the Smithsonian museums
smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/you-wouldnt-have-chocolate-without-invisible-flies-and-extreme-yeast-180954172

We checked it on 31 October 2026

This page tells us how dried beans become chocolate.

Drying and Manufacturing — Cornell University Library's chocolate exhibit
exhibits.library.cornell.edu/chocolate-food-of-the-gods/feature/drying-and-manufacturing

We checked it on 31 October 2026

Has this changed?

Yes, this one changes. The history of cacao has been pushed back before, and “oldest so far” can move again.

How chocolate is made from the bean is not going to change.

Words from this page

cacao
The tree that chocolate comes from, and its seeds.
ferment
To let seeds or dough sit while tiny living things change them.
nibs
Roasted, cracked pieces of cacao bean.

Try it!

Be a wrapper detective.

1. Collect two or three chocolate wrappers. 2. Find the ingredients. Look for cocoa or cacao. 3. Is cocoa listed first or later? (Ingredients are listed from most to least.)

What happens: you can tell which bar has the most cacao, no tasting needed.

Go further